What is the Difference Between a Fixed Deposit and A Debt Mutual Fund?
2022-07-18T15:58:26.000+05:30
2026-04-07T00:00:00.000Z
Shriram Finance
*T&C Apply

What is the Difference Between a Fixed Deposit & a Debt Mutual Fund?

Debt mutual funds are generally considered lower in volatility compared to equity-oriented funds, though they remain subject to interest rate and credit risks. In contrast, a Fixed Deposit (FD) offers returns that are predetermined at the time of booking for the selected tenure, subject to applicable terms. Both FDs and debt mutual funds have distinct features and may serve different investment objectives.

Taxation on debt mutual funds applies at the time of redemption, based on applicable capital gains rules. Fixed deposits, on the other hand, offer features such as the facility to avail of a loan against the deposit, subject to institutional policies.

With changing market conditions, investors often evaluate the balance between return potential and stability. Debt mutual funds provide market-linked returns, which may fluctuate based on underlying portfolio performance. Fixed deposits provide return visibility over a defined tenure.

Shriram Fixed Deposit offers an additional interest benefit may apply on renewals, subject to scheme terms. Investors may review the latest interest rates and scheme details before making a decision.

To understand the differences between a fixed deposit and a debt mutual fund, it is important to first examine how each instrument functions and aligns with individual financial goals.

What is a Debt Mutual Fund?

A Debt Fund is also referred to as Income Fund or Bond Fund and is a mutual fund scheme that invests in fixed income instruments like corporate or government bonds, treasury bills, commercial papers, government securities, etc., offering capital appreciation. Debt mutual funds may be open-ended or close-ended, depending on the scheme structure. Returns are generated through interest income from underlying securities and changes in their market value. They are often considered by investors seeking relatively lower volatility compared to equity-oriented investments.

Features and Benefits of a Debt Mutual Fund

The primary goal of a debt mutual fund is to give you a steady income throughout the investment period. You need to select a specific period to avail of these benefits. Some of the features and benefits you can get by investing in a debt mutual fund:

Debt funds have comparatively lower risks:

Debt mutual funds are influenced by broader economic conditions, including changes in interest rates and credit environments. Since they invest primarily in fixed-income instruments, they are generally considered lower in volatility compared to equity funds. However, returns may vary depending on interest rate movements and the performance of the underlying securities.

Debt Funds Duration:

Investment horizon depends on the type of debt fund selected. Some schemes are open-ended, while others may have a fixed maturity. All debt mutual funds have an investment range from a few months to ten years.

Fixed-Income Security:

Debt mutual funds generate returns through interest and fixed-income securities.

Returns are influenced by prevailing interest rates and credit quality of underlying instruments.

Tax Efficiency:

Capital gains from debt mutual funds are taxed upon redemption, based on the applicable short-term or long-term capital gains rules.

Liquidity:

Most open-ended debt mutual funds allow redemption on business days, subject to applicable exit load and settlement timelines.

What is a Fixed Deposit?

A fixed deposit is a deposit scheme where a lump-sum amount is placed for a selected tenure at a predetermined interest rate, subject to applicable terms. Banks and non-banking financial companies (NBFCs) typically offer tenure options ranging from short-term periods to several years, depending on the scheme.

Shriram Fixed Deposit offers additional interest rates of 0.50%* p.a. for senior citizens and 0.05%* p.a. for women depositors.

Features and Benefits of a Fixed Deposit

A fixed deposit is an investment scheme offered by banks and NBFCs to help you develop good savings habits and grow your wealth simultaneously. You need to invest a lump sum of money for a fixed tenure in an FD. You have the choice of receiving the interest earned periodically or once upon the deposit's maturity. Here are some of the benefits and features of a fixed deposit you need to know:

Consistent Returns:

In a fixed deposit, the interest rate is agreed upon at the time of booking and generally remains applicable for the selected tenure.

You will get the principal amount you invested along with the interest earned upon maturity of the deposit. Market fluctuations usually will not impact your funds, and any revisions to the interest rates are implemented after maturity or at the renewal of the deposit.

Rate of Interest:

The interest rate of a fixed deposit depends on the tenure you select and the financial institution you are investing with. Check the interest rate you receive using the Shriram FD calculator.

Flexible Tenure:

You can select a tenure ranging from 12 months to 60 months. Premature withdrawal may be permitted, subject to applicable terms and penalties.

Returns on Investment:

The interest you earn on an FD depends on the maturity period of the deposit. The longer the tenure of the deposit, the more interest you can make.

In cumulative FDs, interest is compounded and paid at maturity, while non-cumulative FDs provide periodic payouts.

Loan against FD:

Many financial institutions offer the facility to avail of a loan against a fixed deposit, subject to their internal policies and margin requirements. The eligible loan amount is typically a percentage of the deposit value. During the loan tenure, withdrawal of the fixed deposit may be restricted until the loan is repaid, as per applicable terms.

Differences between an FD and a Debt Mutual Fund

Now that we know all the features of a debt mutual fund and FD, we can compare them to see the differences between them:

Features
Fixed Deposit
Debt Mutual Fund
Risk
Low to moderate risk investment
Low-risk investment
Deposit Frequency
Lump sum
Can choose between lump sum and periodical
Returns
Predetermined for selected tenure
Market linked
Premature withdrawal
Premature withdrawal allowed with conditions
Some debt funds have zero charges. But for others, charges will apply

Which Investment Should You Consider?

Based on the above information, the choice between a debt mutual fund and a fixed deposit depends on your investment horizon, liquidity needs, and comfort with market-linked fluctuations. Debt mutual funds provide returns linked to underlying fixed-income securities, while fixed deposits offer return visibility over a selected tenure.

Shriram Fixed Deposit offers interest rates up to 8.15%* p.a., inclusive of additional benefits for eligible categories. Shriram Fixed Deposit is rated "CARE AAA;Stable” by CARE Ratings; “Crisil AA+/Watch Positive” by CRISIL Ratings Limited; [ICRA]AA+/Watch Positive" by ICRA & "IND AA+/Stable" by India Ratings and Research.

You may review the scheme features, tenure options, and applicable interest rates to determine whether they align with your financial objectives.

Key Highlights:

How is a fixed deposit better than a debt mutual fund?

Fixed deposits offer return visibility for a selected tenure, while debt mutual funds provide market-linked returns. The suitability of either depends on an investor’s time horizon, liquidity needs, and risk comfort.

Which is suitable for a longer investment, an FD or a Mutual Fund?

For longer investment horizons, debt mutual funds may be considered by investors comfortable with market-linked returns. Fixed deposits may suit those who prefer predetermined returns over a defined tenure.

What is the level of risk associated with debt funds?

Debt fund returns are influenced by interest rate movements and credit quality of underlying securities. The level of risk varies by scheme type.

Where should I invest: FD or Debt Mutual Funds?

The decision between a fixed deposit and a debt mutual fund depends on your financial goals, liquidity requirements, and tolerance for market-linked fluctuations. Reviewing the features of each option can help determine which aligns better with your overall investment strategy.

related
popular
recent